Rated 5 out of 5 by BillyFrankie Best ever eyeliner for staying power!
Dear Bare Minerals, PLEASE PLEASE bring back this eyeliner. I can honestly say that this is the best eyeliner for staying power I have EVER used, and I am not a young 'un ;o) I think that those who have left negative feedback for it may have been slightly heavy-handed in its application. My answer is to apply it very very lightly, even just dotting it along the line. Hence less product lumping and less pressure on the point, though I do find that being light-handed with it still requires regular sharpening. As I have not been able to get a black/midnight one, I use a dark brown shade, and keep it in the coolest part of the fridge. I hope Bare Minerals read theses reviews and takes notice of their customers' views...
Rated 5 out of 5 by Hrmtanti BRING BACK MIDNIGHT!!!
This eyeliner I have searched for my whole life and when I purchased it I was so happy I bought them constantly when they were in store !! Then I was so upset to hear that they are no longer selling round the clock and the only colors left was 11pm so I bought the 11pm which is good but the midnight had such a amazing darkness about it and was so soft it stayed on all day please bring back midnight we all miss it !!!!!!!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sazi Best eyeliner ever
I have tried every eyeliner in every price bracket and this, without a doubt has the best staying power I have ever experienced. People say it is difficult to sharpen, however easily rectified by firstly having a good quality sharpener and secondly by not keeping it too warm. Keep it in the fridge over night is a solution if it is warm. I am devastated that this has been discontinued and have bought up all the 'midnights' I could find and have had to try out some of the other darker colours. Please bring it back as your replacement eyeliner is not in the same league.
Rated 1 out of 5 by CDubz30 Not an eyeliner for everyone
I have tried to make this product work for me but after several attempts I'm going to have to give up. It is soft so as soon as I touch my eye the point I made with the sharpener (which I have to use way too often with this product I might add) turns into a wide line which I don't want.
After applying I then spend the rest of my day fishing massive clumps of the stuff out of my eye which is irritating beyond measure.
Then when I get home and try to take it off it takes forever! unless you like thick clumpy make up avoid this eyeliner!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jessmoll Great and waterproof
Love the fact it is waterproof. Lasts all day and goes on really well.
Rated 1 out of 5 by ReRe23 Not the worst but not my favorit
I am a die hard fan of the Bere Escentuals brand. It's my favorite make-up, so the fact that I was so disappointed in this eyeliner is a big deal for me. It goes on really thick and makes you feel like you are wearing a lot on your eye lid. It holds up to the name of "round the clock", which is why I gave it the 1 heart. I wouldn't of given it any hearts if I could. It lives up to it name but because of that it's very hard to get off. Like I mentioned before it goes on very thick as well, that was my issues with it. I like liner that is thinner and there is no way to adjust the line. No matter how careful you are it goes on in a glompy think line. I was really existed for a pencil type liner but this was just disappointing.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Bramblebriar The most amazing liner ever
Slips on easy like a gel and wears like iron, all the people who grumped about sharpening problems obviously did not buy a BE sharpener --- match made in heaven! Yes, QUALITY MATTERS! I bought my first pencil in a kit that contained a sharpener, which I thought I did not need since I already had a sharpener, well one sharpening was all it took to make me a believer. The BE sharpener truly is professional quality, shaves off just the thinnest amount with each pass, and the pencil casing is apparently made of some wood composite material which never splinters and drags but has an even consistency without developing those sharp points that tend to jab up around the lead of other pencil liners. I never even tried my old sharpener with this pencil, the precision quality of the BE sharpener was just obviously superior. I imagine that the BE sharpener is engineered to the casing hardness of BE pencils. The sharpener is very definitely a precision tool and I love that it even includes a lil' pokey thing to clean the shreds out with. Even my guy friends were impressed with this sharpener. I used it to illustrate the difference between drugstore grade and professional quality cosmetics, it was an item they could relate to and now they don't think it's at all ridiculous to spend money on quality makeup.
The liner consistency is silky and luxurious with no skipping or pulling, and super-pigmented so a little goes a long ways or glam it up, either way. And holy cow does it ever last! I went out of town and forgot some of my makeup, but even after washing I had enough pigment left along my lashline to get me through the next day.
This eyeliner is everything I ever wished an eyeliner could be and now it's being discontinued??? Maybe BE should have made it more clear that the BE sharpener was the must-have tool for the proper care of this product??? What a shame. Wish I had had a chance to stock up on a lifetime supply, these eyeliners were that good.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jodell This was the ONLY eyeliner I have liked in YEARS!
I can't believe this was discontinued! I am still eking out the last of my brown and plum. It went on like a Kohl liner... but the important thing was it STAYED on! Any other easy to apply liner transfers to the crease of my eye... unless i put powdered shadow over it... With this liner, you can make a pencil thin line or a bolder line... the liner you put out to replace it is too hard to apply. It drags across the eye and you can only make a thicker line... no need for the smudger on the end... Bring back the ROUND THE CLOCK!
Rated 5 out of 5 by GuernseyGirl Perfect water-liner
I am so disappointed that this is being discontinued. The new liner is way too hard for lining along the water line. The Round-The-Clock liners are perfect for lining along the top and bottom waterline (i.e. the inner eye) for an intense kohl look. I have every colour and am now stocking up when I can. This is the only way that I use liner: if I need colour along the outer lash line, I use an eyeshadow with a thin brush.
Bare Minerals, discontinuing this is a mistake: you need to recognise that one type of eyeliner cannot perform every function.
Rated 5 out of 5 by celery Round the clock waterproof Eyeliner all colors
This is the best product that I have ever used, I am a hairdresser and makeup artist and have used this many times.. I AM SO DISAPPOINTED THAT THIS IS DISCONTINUED The replacement eyeliner is no where near as smooth and good as Round the clock is. Please reconsider and bring back...